BMW 3 Series Trumps the Mighty Audi RS4 and S6?

The 3 series got the nod over the Audi RS4 and S6 in the Sport/Performance Car category and will contend for the Car of the Year Award.

The S8 beat out the Mercedes S class and the Lexus LS460L in the prestige category.



TORONTO (Ontario) November 21, 2006 – The 2007 “Best New” winners in thirteen different “Canadian Car of the Year” categories were announced today by the Automobile Journalists Association of Canada (AJAC) at a press conference held at the Holiday Inn Select, in Toronto, Ontario.


The purpose of the Canadian Car of the Year (CCOTY) awards program, created by journalist members of AJAC, is to provide consumers with sound, comparative information on vehicles that are new to the market.


For that reason, the vote results that determined today’s winners are available on the AJAC web site www.ajac.ca, for use by consumers as a resource buying guide when researching the purchase of a new car, truck, SUV, or CUV for 2007. Also available to consumers are the comparative test data derived from the journalists’ extensive 3-day evaluation of 195 new 2007 vehicles in Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario from October 25 – 27, 2007. This annual event is known in the industry as “TestFest”.


2007 CCOTY Chairman Paul Williams commented, “In my opinion, the AJAC Canadian Car of the Year awards are founded on the most objective, informed and thorough evaluation process you'll find. The evaluations are based on back-to-back testing in real-world situations. They're a uniquely Canadian resource for people looking to buy a new vehicle”.


Denis DesRosiers of DesRosiers Automotive Consultants would agree: “As car awards go I personally believe that the Automobile Journalists of Canada (AJAC) serve our industry very well. Their testing process is very thorough and fair involving journalists who evaluate a very wide spectrum of vehicles through the year and thus know how to evaluate a complex product. They come together once a year to evaluate these specific vehicles and their choices are almost always right on the mark.”


AJAC’s three consumer surveys show that winning an AJAC Canadian Car of the Year (CCOTY) award is increasingly important for potential buyers of new cars. For example, a survey of 2004 Canadian Car of the Year buyers confirmed an influence of 58.4%. In 2002 that influence was 47.5%; in 1999 the influence was 44.5%.


The 2007 category winners are:

Best New Small Car (under $18,000): Winner: Honda FIT LX

Best New Small Car (over $18,000): Winner: Volkswagen Rabbit 2.5

Best New Family Car ($22,000 - $30,000): Winner: Toyota Camry LE

Best New Family Car (over $30,000): Winner: Toyota Camry Hybrid

Best New Luxury Car (under $50,000): Winner: Lexus ES 350

Best New Prestige Car: Winner: Audi S8

Best New Sports / Performance Car (under $50,000): Winner: Mazdaspeed3

Best New Sports / Performance Car (over $50,000): Winner: BMW 3-Series Coupé

Best New Convertible: Winner: Volkswagen EOS 2.0T

Best New Pick-up Truck: Winner: Chevrolet Avalanche

Best New SUV / CUV (under $35,000): Winner: Toyota RAV4 - V6 Sport

Best New SUV / CUV ($35,000 - $60,000): Winner: Acura RDX Technology Package

Best New SUV / CUV (over $60,000): Winner: Mercedes-Benz GL Class

The overall Canadian Car of the Year, Canadian Utility Vehicle of the Year, as well as the Canadian Truck of the Year will all be announced on February 14th, 2007, at the 2007 Canadian International Auto Show in Toronto, Ontario. The 2007 Best New Design and Best New Technology winners will also be declared at that time.


And there’s more… our AJAC journalists who evaluated the brand-new models at TestFest are available across Canada for interviews to talk about the vote results and comparative data. Media are invited to visit the AJAC web site and log-in under “Ask The Experts”, then choose the “Car of the Year” link for interviews once they’ve been validated.




EL34EL34 - 11/22/2006 11:46:49 PM
-1 Boost
Acura RDX Technology Package - yuck!


golfer38golfer38 - 11/25/2006 9:43:54 AM
+2 Boost
Anything but German is "yuck".


mstangpny07mstangpny07 - 11/22/2006 11:57:34 PM
+3 Boost
I'm sure the 3er beat them OVERALL, not in the performance category. I'm sure the 3er rode better, handled responsibly, had comfortable seats and suspension....etc. so thats why they chose it over the RS4 and S6 which are harder to live with on a day-to-day basis. (Stiff ride, noisy engine (good for us, bad for them) stiff seats, harder, larger tires, and a steep price.


sewingmachinesewingmachine - 11/23/2006 5:19:40 AM
+2 Boost
its not just one judge its all of themn, i think.


mstangpny07mstangpny07 - 11/23/2006 9:03:35 AM
+3 Boost
I did say "good for us, bad for them" meaning we like noisy (loud) engines, but somebody who drives a camry might not.
When I meant the ride better, I mean less stiff and harsh.
The ride in a 328i and a RS4 must be totally different.
I know it was performance, but it wasn't "exotic" so it must be livable day to day,
MDalle's post is very good. That's what I meant.


ChipChip - 11/23/2006 6:11:19 AM
0 Boost
Audi dealers arent letting people drive the new RS4 without a commitment to buy.


S4cabriofoxoneS4cabriofoxone - 11/23/2006 12:11:32 AM
+2 Boost
And you used this title, why, I ask you?

You're trying too hard, again. See mstangpny's post.

The RS4 is obviously a more performance-oriented car (and MUCH faster), but the 3 Series is easier to live with.

And you only mention that the S8 won, in passing.

Well, at least you recognize it. If this were AmazingBimmer's post, he wouldn't mention the S8 winning at all.




S4cabriofoxoneS4cabriofoxone - 11/23/2006 12:12:23 AM
-1 Boost
Oh, and the 3 Series coupe is not over $50,000, so I don't see how they included it in the "Over $50,000" category. The base price for the 335i is about $42K, I think.


rom64rom64 - 11/23/2006 12:26:19 AM
+2 Boost
Wow! This list of cars is spot on. Couldn't have chosen any others myself.


blueice4589blueice4589 - 11/23/2006 12:46:05 AM
-2 Boost
Was the Chevrolet Avalanche Redesigned or something? Cuz how is it NEW?


blueice4589blueice4589 - 11/23/2006 12:47:06 AM
-1 Boost
NEVERMIND!! IT WAS!! MY BAD!!!!


adamdsadamds - 11/23/2006 9:34:21 AM
-2 Boost
If BMW made the AWD 335xi in a convertible, Audi wouldn't sell another S4. I would love to buy one...


S4cabriofoxoneS4cabriofoxone - 11/23/2006 10:32:25 AM
-1 Boost
Uhh, yeah, Audi would. Take it from me!


S4cabriofoxoneS4cabriofoxone - 11/23/2006 10:32:12 PM
-1 Boost
Well, one problem with that comparison, MDalle, is that the RS4 Cabriolet may not be in production any more when the new M3 comes out. Audi's RS-cars are VERY limited. I would test drive an RS4 convertible soon and take what you can get. Get an M3 when you get rid of it.


AmazingBimmerAmazingBimmer - 11/23/2006 10:59:47 AM
+1 Boost
to be expected. why is this a surprise to anyone.? wait.. here comes the m3.... be afraid...very afraid!!


chewychewy - 11/23/2006 2:30:39 PM
0 Boost
Expensive cars usually don't win Car of the Year honors as those are given out to mainstream cars like the Toyota Camry. But take a look at this:

Best New Small Car (over $18,000): Winner: Volkswagen Rabbit 2.5

Best New Prestige Car: Winner: Audi S8 [where is BMW or Mercedes or Lexus???]

Best New Convertible: Winner: Volkswagen EOS 2.0T






synxsynx - 11/23/2006 2:45:01 PM
0 Boost
Japs beat the Germans 7-5, lexus_dude i'm waiting... (for a snide comment on how lexus cars are the best)

what is the plural of lexus???


RupertRupert - 11/23/2006 5:56:57 PM
+2 Boost
i'd say lexi is the plural of lexus.
like walri (walrus), octopi (octopus), hippopotami (you can guess than one)


mstangpny07mstangpny07 - 11/23/2006 10:17:32 PM
0 Boost
lexuses


S4cabriofoxoneS4cabriofoxone - 11/23/2006 10:36:16 PM
+1 Boost
Or cacti. I love cacti!


GermanNutGermanNut - 11/23/2006 3:46:25 PM
0 Boost
AmazingBimmer, we don't have to be afraid just yet because the M3 is not out yet.

When it comes out then we can be afraid, but not yet.


GermanNutGermanNut - 11/23/2006 3:57:35 PM
-2 Boost
Kind of not, bceause the R8 is coming this upcoming Spring, meanwhile the M3 won't be out until September at earliest.


S4cabriofoxoneS4cabriofoxone - 11/23/2006 10:36:49 PM
+1 Boost
GermanNut, you try too hard.


AmazingBimmerAmazingBimmer - 11/24/2006 7:51:33 AM
0 Boost
yes, s4.. he tries hard. i am surprised by his resilience in the face of data.


indoctrin8edindoctrin8ed - 11/24/2006 2:55:19 PM
+2 Boost
You guys all took the headline bait.

This contest was about "Value proposition to the masses", not lap-time junkies like us that love a stiff suspension and enjoy drifting a corner every chance we can get away with it.

I'd have to agree with the judges that, *for the money*, and, *for the masses*, the 335i coupe is the best bang for buck out there.

Everyone knows the RS4 is "more car" than a 3 series, but it's also way "more buck". A Ferarri 575 is also "more car", but didn't win obviously. It's about Value. The current M3 is a more capable sports car than the 335i is too, but it didn't win either.

Other cars that were probably eliminated because of disproporationate value proposition to the masses would include all BMW M cars, all AMG Mercedes, All Audi "S cars", and likely all Porsches since they are too expensive.

I'll bet the contenters in the 50k+ bracket were: Audi A4/A6, Merc E500, BMW 5-series, Acura TL, Jag XK, Lexus IS350,GS350-430, Mazda RX8, Infinity G35,M45, US: Corvette/GTO/M300/Cad CTS & STS/Mustang SVT/Crossfire, etc.

Anyone still think the 335i coupe shouldn't win in this lineup?



S4cabriofoxoneS4cabriofoxone - 11/25/2006 10:33:26 PM
+2 Boost
Very true. CPILLAR should've acknowledged the fact that the M3, M5 and M6 weren't chosen, either. And the 335i is probably the best value for a sporty car that's on the market right now. It's beautiful, fast, and semi-affordable.


Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC