Auto Spies picks the 2005 'Car of the year'


Click Here


Not only do we get to drive the world's finest cars, travel and dine in some of the best places on earth but we also get the excruciating task of picking the 2005 Car of the year.

That means driving cars, visiting car dealers, talking to customers and generally just goofing off...We mean working our fingers to the bone! ;)

We consider the Auto Spies 'Car of the year' award the MOST prestigious award a car manufacturer can win from the media because it is the ONLY one that is not influenced by ad dollars or political correctness.

We tell it like it is and we don't care WHO doesn't like it.

So with no further ado, Auto Spies names the ‘2005 Car of the year’










What we like about the 997(Regular and 'S' version)-

Porsche goes back in time and resurrects the look of the best looking 911 ever (993) and improves it significantly. The design is timeless yet modern even though the average Joe probably couldn’t tell the difference between it and the 996. Open the door and enjoy interior design, quality and finish you would expect in a car of that price. But the most important thing on any Porsche, or any fine car for that matter, is how it drives. And WHAT a difference! You can drive it and find something to like about it every single time you turn the key! Very few compromises here. For the money, it’s the best daily driver sports car (non four-door sport sedan) on the planet. It’s just right in EVERY gear and you don’t have to mortgage your house to get it fixed. In the words of Billy Joel…’I love you just the way you are’.

What we would improve-

Not much to improve but at these prices we’re allowed to be nitpickers

1. Where’s the integrated satellite radio option?
2. Keyless go option would be nice.
3. Integrated plug-in for iPod.
4. More new wheel style choices.
5. Better integrated phone solution choices.
6. Bose stereo still not the best

Customer opinion:

Just blagged a test drive in the new 997 from the dealer I am buying mine from and in final production form (as apposed to my recent test track drive), it's hard to believe that Porsche could have made the car any better.

The engine is super-smooth, throttle response equally so, handling breathtaking, steering was sharp and the ride over the crummy UK roads was like a Bentley not a go kart, as I expected. Brakes were terrific and the leather lined interior was a well put together as Porkers of old, indeed the door clunked shut, not clicked shut like the 996. Importantly this was a stock 997 Carrera (not an S) with no fancy options.

I am waiting with anticipation for mine, due in March. Some will disagree, but the Germans seem to have made a great car even better and in the UK at least, £58,000 doesn't by much fancy stuff (half a Ferrari 430 for example). Don't knock it until you've tried it as Julius Caesar once said.

LD
______________________________________________

We’ve also included the list of cars that made the short list for the award.

All the cars on the list had their own special merits and we were impressed with all of the list makers.

Anyone who is on this list should not feel slighted and be extremely proud. When you’re talking about cars this good you’re splitting hairs!

The runners-up (not in order of preference):

Ford GT
Corvette
Cadillac STS
New Audi A6
Mercedes-Benz SLK350
Mercedes-Benz SLR
Aston DB9
Bentley Continental
Ferrari Scaglietti
Maserati Quattroporte
Lotus Elise


rackrack - 9/23/2004 10:23:18 PM
+1 Boost
I second the sl55.


993Turbo993Turbo - 9/24/2004 3:06:04 AM
+1 Boost
SL55 is great but is a lead sled and doestn't handle half as good as a porsche.


tblacktblack - 9/24/2004 6:53:32 AM
+1 Boost
Nice pick! This car is so much more a 911 than the 006 ever was/is. Good to see a great looking P-car again.


tblacktblack - 9/24/2004 6:53:32 AM
+1 Boost
Nice pick! This car is so much more a 911 than the 006 ever was/is. Good to see a great looking P-car again.


tblacktblack - 9/24/2004 6:57:14 AM
+1 Boost
OOPS! 006 should be 996. Finger fatigue.


tblacktblack - 9/24/2004 6:57:14 AM
+1 Boost
OOPS! 006 should be 996. Finger fatigue.


rocket109rocket109 - 9/24/2004 7:57:00 AM
+1 Boost
I am surprised not to see the MB E55 AMG on this list. In earlier editions you raved about the car but no mention here. It has everything a person could want, style, comfort, power, luxury, sportiness to metion just a few. What's up? Thank you hopefully for a response. Keep up the good work!


AssassinZO6AssassinZO6 - 9/25/2004 2:46:50 PM
+1 Boost
In my opinion the car of the year should go to the Lotus Elise. It outperforms and is one cool car. The 997 can not come close in offering supreme performance. And at least it's priced somewhat affordable.


yrralis1yrralis1 - 9/28/2004 9:52:31 PM
+1 Boost
Two days ago I received a call from the salesman who sold me the "S" last month . After owning five Porsches (three I bought from him) he felt compelled to ask my opinion of this car . I told him that it is by far the best 911 I have ever owned .As I clicked on your article I was very pleased to see that you selected this car. Although my likes and dislikes might differ somewhat from yours , we do agree in one area : it's a great car with not improvement needed .
I love the car . I do recommend the S model and although the options do add up --some of them are well worth it . My personal favorite is by far --the ceramic brakes . They stop on dime and have no brake dust . The sport adaptive seats are also incredibly functional and comfortable .The Sport Chrono gives a remarkable responsive ride and throttle --yet I do feel that the sport mode switch ought to be placed on the steering wheel .
I agree with you folks on the wheels . The "cut out" wheels are acceptable but I would have preferred a wide selection . Also the two small lights which illuminate the rear tag loosen easily . This was a problem with my 996 as well . I agree that the Bose sound system is not the best -- and I applaud you guys raising awareness . I don't care for things like satellite radio and keyless go . I prefer simplicity . In fact --my car has a navigation system and honestly I think it's easier to just ask for directions than to type in the destination.


Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC