Auto Spies picks the 2005 'SUV of the year' Part one





Not only do we get to drive the world's finest cars, trucks and SUV’s, travel and dine in some of the best places on earth but we also get the excruciating task of picking the 2005 SUV of the year.

That means driving cars, visiting car dealers, talking to customers and generally just goofing off...We mean working our fingers to the bone! ;)

We consider the Auto Spies 'SUV of the year' award the MOST prestigious award a car manufacturer can win from the media because it is the ONLY one that is not influenced by ad dollars or political correctness.

We tell it like it is and we don't care WHO doesn't like it.

So with no further ado, Auto Spies names the ‘2005 SUV of the year’




The Land Rover LR3- ‘The Range rover for the rest of us’



What we like about it...

First of all, the new LR3 is a 100% improvement over the Discovery.

We’re drawn to the elegant and tasteful design. In certain ways, we like it BETTER than the Range rover. Think of it as a Range Rover with a third row seat.



The interior design and ergonomics are superlative. Everything is in the right place and it is extremely pleasing to the eye.



It has the right mix of power and toughness.

If you can only afford one vehicle and you need to do it all…this is it!

What we would improve-

1. Where’s the integrated satellite radio option?
2. Keyless go option would be nice.
3. Integrated plug-in for iPod.
4. Unproven reliability record

We’ve also included the list of SUV’s that made the short list for the award.

All the SUV’s on the list had their own special merits and we were impressed with all of the list makers.

Anyone who is on this list should not feel slighted and be extremely proud. When you’re talking about cars this good you’re splitting hairs!

The runners-up (not in order of preference...next week we will list in order of preference):

BMW X5 4.8is
Range Rover
Infiniti QX56
Lexus LX470
Infiniti FX45
VW Touareg
Porsche Cayenne
Audi All-road
Volvo XC90
Acura MDX
Lexus RX330

More photos in part two

GregWinOregonGregWinOregon - 10/14/2004 9:07:58 PM
+1 Boost
I am looking to replace my '98 ML 320, and the LR3 is attractive in many ways. It's about the right size--plenty of room, but not huge. I don't need or want a 3rd row seat, but it's optional. I like the design a lot.

Two things bother me--(1) Only one engine option. The V8 looks reasonable in terms of performance, but it's really thirsty. (2) Reliability--The latest 3 year quality study I saw had LR and the absolute bottom. I hope Ford is turning things around, but hope is not good enough for me.

I'm holding out for the W164 M-B ML next year. Should be a choice of 4-valve V6 & V8, 7-speed, etc.


MercBasherMercBasher - 10/14/2004 10:49:31 PM
+1 Boost
The LR3 is a safe but pedestrian selection. Question is two years from now if the reliable is shocking (re on a par with Mercedes) will 001 lower the ratings on the LR3

Separately what is the value proposition for the Range Rover now that the cheaper LR3 does everything better than the RR can?


MercBasherMercBasher - 10/14/2004 11:12:58 PM
+1 Boost
Here are the top three entry and premium luxury SUVs as determined by a survey of buyers. Note no Land Rover products made it for 2004...maybe the LR3 will make it in 2005. In the meantime the three Lexus SUVs lead the way in this study by JD Powers.

Entry Luxury SUV
Highest Ranked: Lexus RX 330
Infiniti FX-Series
BMW X5

Premium Luxury SUV
Highest Ranked: Lexus LX 470
Lexus GX 470
Cadillac Escalade/Escalade ESV

Source: J.D. Power and Associates 2004 Automotive Performance, Execution and Layout (APEAL) StudySM



elviososaelviososa - 10/16/2004 8:40:25 AM
+1 Boost
Hey be real ok!?....How many of you will take a brand new $30K or ++ SUV off road??? Beside, I think Land Rover is over priced.


rackrack - 10/21/2004 6:14:57 AM
+1 Boost
"Title: LR3 is a clear winner
Comment: Now if you want a luxury couch on wheels (Lexus), this isn't your vehicle... but as a true SUV, this is the one to beat. Really. A little overpriced for my taste, but excellent."

Youe confusing the Lexus SUV's w/ a Escalade.

The Lexus LX/GX are extremely capable offroad. I recently drove all 3 of them at the taste of luxury event, and the lexus vehicles seemed to do better in some areas than the RR. I was especially impressed with the GX's capabilities. It cruised through obstacles that made even the rr make some odd noises.



Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC