Top story: Review: Auto Spies first impression-Porsche Cayman



Before I go into detail and give you a verdict on the new Porsche Cayman, I will share with you my initial thoughts that came to mind, when I first saw the real pics of the Cayman.

First thoughts that came to my mind:

Why?
It's the coolest looking Mazda ever.
I wouldn't personally buy it.
If you have 65K, what's another 5-10k for a 911?
Why not bring out a lower price Boxster?
Why not a base 997 for 65K?
Same fate as the M Coupe, although not as ugly?
Are there really that many customers asking for this?
$65K...that's a lot of dough for what you get!

That said, here is my verdict:

I'll give the Cayman a B-minus for it's intial grade.

Not bad looking although it does not deliver on the promise that it would be the best looking sports car Porsche makes.

It's also the most 'Asian' looking product Porsche has ever made in my opinion.

Overall it is kind of cool, but I don't think the market is there for the car (outside of the intial adopters who will buy anything with a prestige badge on it).

I like the performance specs most of all but do you want 911 owners to know for $10K less another Porsche will KILL it on a track?

I would have made a $65K base price 911 if I was running things.

Do you agree with me or am I way off here?


SteveSteve - 6/2/2005 8:12:23 PM
+1 Boost
While I have not driven the Cayman, I agree with 001 on all other counts. It's a non-event in my books.


SteveSteve - 6/2/2005 8:12:23 PM
+1 Boost
While I have not driven the Cayman, I agree with 001 on all other counts. It's a non-event in my books.


DiamondJimDiamondJim - 6/2/2005 9:33:35 PM
+1 Boost
"If you have 65K, what's another 5-10k for a 911?"

For 65K or 5-10K more, you can get a SEXY Mercedes CLS.......


MercBasherMercBasher - 6/2/2005 10:47:58 PM
+1 Boost
You're dead-on. Surely for all the design/engineering effort that went into the Cayman the resources could have been applied to the 911 or to a cheaper Boxster hard top.
Thing is we [you and I] didn't spend millions on market research so just maybe Porsche knows what its doing - but I doubt it!


Matthew1Matthew1 - 6/2/2005 11:38:40 PM
+1 Boost
The Cayman is a very beautiful car, and the best Porsche design for a long time. Its wondefully balanced, has a very sleek profile, and is extremely well detailed, without being fussy.

It is certainly no Mazda, that comment is laughable. B-? Maybe you should reserve judgement until you see one on the street, and not just in a photo.


993Turbo993Turbo - 6/3/2005 6:39:43 AM
+1 Boost
The 911 is finished. After the current turbo comes out, there will be nothing left to wring out of the platform. The cayman is significant because it easily outhandles the Carrera with less power and sells for less money. This is a wonderful concept called value. I'm a 911 fan and own a 96 twin turbo but if the current 911 is the "perfect" car that every journalist says it is, then it will eventually languish in its perfection. Porsche needs the mid-engine platform to evolve into a higher plane of performance.


993Turbo993Turbo - 6/3/2005 6:44:16 AM
+1 Boost
Oh, and thank heavens they broke up those butt fugly gaping holes in the nose!


tarponspringstarponsprings - 6/3/2005 7:33:45 AM
+1 Boost
From SniffPetrol.com:

"Porsche's new Cayman coupe is hugely significant, not only because it gives the German sports car maker a fourth model line and hence something for Autocar to use as a cover story for the next six months, but also because it allows the company to maintain its lead in having the most confusing model line up in the world. "That's right," agreed a spokesman, somewhat unnecessarily. "For too long we have ignored customers who want a Porsche that almost looks like a 911, that's almost as fast as a 911 and costs almost as much as a 911 but that isn't a 911. And now they can buy one. Almost".
The Cayman's introduction will come as a relief to Porsche management who had privately expressed concern that the company's range was losing its edge, in particular against child's plaything sports car manufacturer TVR which has maintained a strong confusion edge with a range of models that are all about the same size and price and performance for no explicable reason whatsoever.
In the past Porsche's confusion performance had entirely to revolve around the 911 range itself with a needless and baffling proliferation of two- and four-wheel-drive variants featuring slightly difference engines, power outputs, body styles and funny spoiler things on the leading edge of the bonnet. Spies say the Cayman finally allows the Boxster platform to play a crucial role in spreading confusion, along with the Cayenne, the success of which continues to confuse everyone because it's completely irrelevant and looks shit"


DGP1435DGP1435 - 6/6/2005 1:19:17 AM
+1 Boost
Folks -

You need to re-think your feelings about the CaymanS.

Some of you don't like the looks of the car. Fine; we all have different taste.

But on the price issue: If last year Porsche had announced that it would build a new car line, that the new car would outperform the 911, and that it would cost $10k LESS than the 911, we'd have all been thrilled. Well, they just did that. Thank you, Porsche!

So instead of complaining that it's more expensive than the BoxsterS, think of it this way: they just undercut their own top-line product. There are still reasons to love the 911; but for those who want comparable performance for a lower price, now we have a new alternative.


elviososaelviososa - 6/6/2005 4:48:55 PM
+1 Boost
AGREE....nn this one!


jlukawitzM32008jlukawitzM32008 - 6/9/2005 7:26:58 AM
+1 Boost
I originally went to the dealer to place a "pre-order" for the vehicle, my name is/was on the top of the list to receive one of the first, but after seeing the pictures, coupled with the anticipated pricing, and I think the 911 is the route I will take.

Overall, I am not impressed, the Cayman looks almost toylike in profile, and cartoonish.




Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC