Which retro ride is the coolest? Challenger, Camaro or Mustang. And how dead IS retro?

Which retro ride is the coolest? Challenger, Camaro or Mustang. And how dead IS retro?
Anticipation has certainly run high as muscle car fans eagerly await the return of the Camaro.  Chevrolet has given us the first official pictures of the forthcoming Camaro, and based on initial impressions the production car holds true to the concept car many have lusted over for the past few years.



Of course had it not been for the success of the Mustang and its retro inspired sheet metal, perhaps the Camaro might never have been brought back.  Dodge quickly hopped on the retro train, first in introducing their thoroughly modern Hemi engine, and then by bringing the Challenger to market.




For the muscle car fan, heck for the car enthusiast in general, the availability of such cars at a price most can afford should bring a smile to your face.  Horsepower, handling and style are all hallmarks of the Mustang, Challenger and Camaro.  But all three share a common thread in that they elicit an emotion inside brought on by the cars they draw inspiration from, all cars of the past.

Retro design has been with us for almost 10 years now.  Volkswagen really started the whole retro revolution with their New Beetle.  Ford followed suit shortly thereafter with the Thunderbird.  BMW revived a whole brand in bringing us the Mini Cooper, a car that virtually created a new segment with the premium small car concept.

But is Retro past its prime, and should car makers be looking to catch the wave of the next hot thing.

Let’s face it, when the Mustang hit dealers lots it created a lot of excitement and buzz because of the car it so closely resembled, and yet today few of us even give the Mustang a second glance when we see it on the road.  Retro is cool, but retro certainly has a shelf life.  Both Dodge and Chevy brought products to market based on the success of the Mustang, but where do they go from here?  The Mustang has always been a strong selling car for Ford.  When previous generation Camaros and Firebirds were still for sale, Ford easily outsold those models with the Mustang, a fact that led to the eventual death of both offerings from General Motors.

Will the Challenger and Camaro both be one hit wonders, or do they have the staying power to truly become successful model lines for Dodge and GM?  Time will ultimately be the judge and juror, but if retro is past its prime, what happens to the replacements for the Challenger and Camaro after their shelf lives expire?

So I guess it boils down to this, which (if any) of the three would you choose to drive, and do you think retro is past its prime and a new design language be instituted for future models?

In asking the question I also want to answer from my perspective.  I love the look of the Challenger, but the fact that no manual transmission is available on the SRT-8, I would probably go with the Camaro SS with the 6-Speed manual.  In terms of the whole retro design, I do have to say that I feel as though it certainly has a “been there done that” feel to it.

Of course it is my opinion, we want to know what you think…


Read Article

themantheman - 7/18/2008 11:54:09 PM
+9 Boost
I like the Challenger the most..


EnnNorakEnnNorak - 7/19/2008 11:34:28 AM
-2 Boost
As for looks, Mustang takes the cake but none of that stuff is cool anyway. Cool would be a restored 1972 Chrysler Imperial on a brand new custom-fabricated stainless-steel frame and a souped-up 572 cu. in. GM crate motor.


bfghemicudabfghemicuda - 7/23/2008 8:22:31 PM
+1 Boost
When you build a mopar you stay with a mopar crate engine. Keep your GM engines in your GM cars. Now, an old Imperial with a 500 wedge injected, Skirted block cross bolted mains better induction etc.


BmwVoyagerBmwVoyager - 7/19/2008 12:11:03 AM
+2 Boost
The Challenger takes my eye...
The Camaro looks like a plastic car ;<
and the mustang........its just eh


WorldofLuxuryWorldofLuxury - 7/19/2008 12:16:03 AM
+2 Boost
Mustang has been out for a while and still looks good.
The Challenger is awesome...true muscle car.
And the Camaro is cool in its own way...I like its modern touch.

They're all winners, and I'd say choosing just one of them would be the hardest decision of my life.


exgmerexgmer - 7/19/2008 12:18:17 AM
+4 Boost
While the Challenger is cool in that is it the most retro, it doesn't do much for me (especially the cheap interior)

I like the Mustang and will be interesting to see what Ford does with its own upcoming update.

For now it's definitely the Camaro for me. The exterior has retro cues but seems much more modern overall. I also think the interior design is head and shoulders above the others. Yes, it's seems like it's been quite a wait from the time the concept was unveiled, but it seems that GM is really focused on doing it right.




Agent63Agent63 - 7/19/2008 12:29:21 AM
+2 Boost
Coolest I would probably have to say the Camaro. I think the interior for the 'maro is the best. However if you want retro styling for an interior the Challenger is the winner.


nsmattnsmatt - 7/19/2008 12:37:14 AM
+1 Boost
Challenger: reserved, and looks like it's bursting at the seams with power. I love it.


eric452eric452 - 7/19/2008 1:43:25 AM
+2 Boost
CHALLENGER LOOKS SICK!
Camaro is ok
and mustang is to common on the roads


eric452eric452 - 7/19/2008 3:00:28 PM
+2 Boost
fyi
sick is a good thing


toolatetoracetoolatetorace - 7/19/2008 10:22:09 AM
+2 Boost
you better put your glasses on


chewychewy - 7/19/2008 2:31:50 AM
0 Boost
Camaro, less retro and the best performance.


MunichRobMunichRob - 7/19/2008 4:39:57 AM
-2 Boost
I'd go with the Challenger as it's the most powerful & IMO best looking.


ilmorilmor - 7/19/2008 6:29:20 AM
+2 Boost
Give me the Mustang any day over the others - and bear in mind that the current Mustang has been out since 2004, and in 2010 there will be a new model. The Challenger is a shortened 300, and is much too big and heavy at over 2 tons. The Camaro is way overstyled and looks like it was designed by aliens, plus it is also too heavy at 3700 lbs. The Mustang has and always will be the leader in this group, which is why it has been around since it started in '64 and the others have not!


PrancingHorsePrancingHorse - 7/19/2008 7:51:51 AM
-8 Boost
All 3 are "cartoon" styled cars that wont be able to take a corner faster than 50 mph.US car companies are such a joke they come up with a nice initial design sketch and all the trailer trash gets excited than 5-6 yrs later they produce the car that now has gone through the bean counters and financial department and you have a overweight,over powered (for the outdated chassis) underperforming car that can be be beat by most cars with half as many cylinders and half the price.US cars just like most US people all show and no go.


fuelfoolfuelfool - 7/20/2008 1:38:32 AM
+2 Boost
Do you rely on gross generalizations and bigoted stereotypes to make all your decisions?


Htay7500Htay7500 - 7/19/2008 7:57:38 AM
+3 Boost
challenger.


iepurilahiepurilah - 7/19/2008 8:33:58 AM
+2 Boost
Like someone else said above, the Challenger looks more retro than the other, but I have to go with the Camaro. It's just awesome.


2JayZee2JayZee - 7/19/2008 9:47:59 AM
+2 Boost
Challenger
Mustang
Camaro


toolatetoracetoolatetorace - 7/19/2008 10:31:57 AM
+2 Boost
Who said retro is dead . I was going to post this as soon as I saw the article but, damicko beat me to it . It is very refreshing to look at cars that are not so government inspired , cars with the ultra areo look, and anteater looking cars along with cars that are inspired by aplliance makers


bmwdrvrbmwdrvr - 7/19/2008 10:22:52 AM
+2 Boost
i like the Camaro the best, it sorta puts the other cars to shame from an interior styling stand point, and it also in my opinion doesnt have the overly retro styling of the challenger, or the cheap look of the mustang


ToneeTonee - 7/19/2008 10:36:54 AM
-1 Boost
Mustang
Camaro
Challenger

P.S. Can anyone tell why Chevrolet decided to steal the rims right off of a Mazda RX-8?


spyderz007_X5spyderz007_X5 - 7/19/2008 12:45:48 PM
+1 Boost
Challenger
Camero
Mustang


mpwrmpwr - 7/19/2008 2:01:00 PM
0 Boost
Mustang
Challenger
Camaro





BMW4me4everBMW4me4ever - 7/19/2008 2:02:23 PM
+2 Boost
Challenger .. it of the cars most closely recreates and takes you back in time.


CarboyCarboy - 7/19/2008 2:40:10 PM
+1 Boost
Is there an all three option?


DenaliDenali - 7/19/2008 6:36:15 PM
+1 Boost
Challenger overall, i still like how bumblebee looks in black

Mustang, do they still make those?


85bmw745i85bmw745i - 7/19/2008 8:10:59 PM
+2 Boost
Exterior challenger, interior camaro.


fuelfoolfuelfool - 7/20/2008 1:40:41 AM
+2 Boost
Have to go with the Challenger in black.


valhallakeyvalhallakey - 7/20/2008 2:39:10 AM
+1 Boost
GM should attempt to make the Camaro a model something along the lines of BMWs 3 series. Make a similarly styled 4 dr sedan and wagon. Put a 6 (turbo and non-turbo) in the mainstream models but keep them very sporting and add some nice trick high end luxury options. Camaro for me... IRS, modern chassis and good looks take it.


CanadaCraigCanadaCraig - 7/20/2008 4:28:14 AM
+2 Boost
A great design NEVER goes out of style. It's just put away for awhile because people [North Americans mostly] want 'new' even if 'new' is worse. They want 'change' for the sake of 'change'. The original Challengers [Not to be confused with the Mitsubishi 'Challengers'] and the early Camaros and Mustangs were great looking cars. And they are STILL great looking cars. So how could it possibly be a bad thing to bring back a 'look' that has already proven itself to be a success? It can't be. Beautifully designed cars will only die if people are stupid enough to let them die. Does anyone think of the Porsche 911 as a 'retro' car? If not - WHY NOT? Because Porsche never allowed that 'look' to become dormant in the first place.

That said...

In order of preference...

Challenger
Mustang
Camaro

As for the Challenger interiors being 'cheap' - perhaps some of you should sit in a new Mustang for awhile. I'm not quite sure what you're comparing the Challenger's interior to.

Craig!! :o)


85bmw745i85bmw745i - 7/20/2008 9:25:43 AM
+3 Boost
Just wait another 20 years when the mustang goes retro 80's lol then the camaro will bring back the Iroc-Z in retro form. Chrysler can bring a retro K-car 2 door, you remember, the one that had a 4 cylinder and had a hemi badge on it lol, or maybe a retro of the 80's Daytona/LeBarron lol.


iamdabest1iamdabest1 - 7/20/2008 11:09:55 AM
+1 Boost
they are all nice , the challenger looks most gangster retro.... but im a camaro guy personally.


carguy68carguy68 - 7/21/2008 11:06:27 AM
+1 Boost
mustang
challenger
& the other car.


mkk21mkk21 - 7/21/2008 3:11:00 PM
+1 Boost
Never really cared for the retro look. IMHO, the retro look is like taking the easy way out. No creativity, no imagination, no skill. Just take an old design and update it. Among all the american brands I give Cadillac the most praise for reviving the company without going the retro route.


bfghemicudabfghemicuda - 7/23/2008 8:17:56 PM
+1 Boost
Challenger


2007Tahoe2007Tahoe - 7/24/2008 11:27:51 PM
+1 Boost
I like both the Challenger and the Camaro, but the Camaro's going to be too late to the party. Still a nice car. I'm curious why GM is taking so long to develop this car, when the ZR1 took less than that to build. We've known about the Camaro for what, 2-3 years now? The ZR1 less than a year?


Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC