BMW Fender Gills- Are they the price of admission for Luxury Styling?

BMW Fender Gills-  Are they the price of admission for Luxury Styling?
I am baffled by a recent phenomenon in the automotive styling world. It seems non-functional, plastic fender gills are now the price of entry in the luxury market. I first took notice of this trend in the 2000 BMW M3.

The overall styling of the E46 M3 was primarily non-offensive, excluding the cancerous growth on the hood dubbed "the power dome" and the plastic gills on the fenders.

The M3 gills coincided with the BMW Z8, a supercar with super-retro styling sans LSD. I liked the Z8, at the time, and appreciated the styling throw-back to the BMW 507, but why did these plasticy gills end up on the M3 and were they here to stay?

I didn't ask any of these questions at the time, but the E60 BMW M5 introduced in 2005 indicated the gills were here to stay and are now one of the most visible M styling cues.

Unfortunately, gills did not stop at the M5. You can see them on Cadillacs, Jaguars, Range Rovers, Minis and the 2008 M3, complete with holes in the hood, a-la Evo, to complement a larger, more cancerous "Power Dome."

Don't think it stopped with the M3. The new Ford Focus, Pontiac G8 and Hyundai Tiburon also get in on the gill action. The new EVO has upped the ante with this:

and the Lexus IS-F followed suit:

Where did this trend start? Why did it start and when will it end?

Origins
The 1956 BMW 507 is one of the first cars with this style gill I can put my finger on. I am sure there may have been others, but you can trace the BMW Z8 and future gills back to this car. It really compliments this car and doesn't seem like the plastic add-ons of today's cars.


Modern Day
The 1987 Buick GNX is the first modern car I can remember with the plastic side gills. I take them at their word that these gills were needed for cooling the engine compartment due to the turbo.

What's Next?
Now that everybody, including Ford & Hyundai, have copied the gill treatment, how long will these unsightly blemishes grace the luxury car market?
Read Article

altdudealtdude - 11/27/2008 10:44:01 AM
+4 Boost
Actually the first Buicks to have the portholes you're thinking of were 1949 models. But before that, Buicks (and other cars) have had side vents since the 30's!

Basically, I think we're really noticing it now since it's being brought back as a styling element rather than something necessary for the car's functionality.


synxsynx - 11/27/2008 5:10:36 AM
+2 Boost
yeah, i agree. i think they make a big difference to the look of the car


t_bonet_bone - 11/27/2008 10:01:59 AM
+4 Boost
You forgot one of the worst very recent examples: the Porsche Panamera.


EL34EL34 - 11/27/2008 11:33:17 AM
+2 Boost
Paying for extra design accents goes back thousands of years.


mmmpowrmmmpowr - 11/27/2008 1:06:41 PM
+1 Boost
senorgato: why don't you check out some of the prewar BMW's such as the 326/327 with their gills.


LarryLarry - 11/27/2008 12:41:44 PM
0 Boost
Gills look cool, cadillac and mercedes also use gills


AE86AE86 - 11/27/2008 2:40:56 PM
0 Boost
Just because BMW recycled a pre-war functional styling cue, why do all car makers blindly follow suit?


JUGNUJUGNU - 11/27/2008 3:37:31 PM
+1 Boost
Porsche Panamera also got fender gills which look very similar to Lexus IS-F.

JUGNU


M53RM53R - 11/27/2008 4:15:11 PM
+1 Boost
The E92 M3's fender gills look very nice. They dont look too ricy.


AE86AE86 - 11/27/2008 9:40:35 PM
+1 Boost
What about the holes in the hood? They are definitely ricey. Don't try to convince me they are necessary. The M5 with the V10 has no holes in the hood. The M3's V8 is derived from the V10...


M53RM53R - 11/29/2008 6:19:57 AM
+1 Boost
The holes on the hood look ricey, I can't deny that. But they don't look like an overkill.


M53RM53R - 11/29/2008 6:25:08 AM
+1 Boost
and they blend really well with the rest of the design.


RefuGRefuG - 11/27/2008 9:40:29 PM
+1 Boost
Fender gills are fine by all means only if they come on production cars.

BUT, when I see some dumb snob rollin in a Sentra, Chrysler 300, Charger or whatever.. with a set of fender gills...man that jus makes me sick.

I've seen so many cars with fender gills, where they had no business being there and which were bought at AutoZone, Checkers, Walmart...Got pics too prove it! lol.

People jus put those vents as an entertainment to myself...and an unknown embarassment to them!


G


AE86AE86 - 11/27/2008 9:42:40 PM
+1 Boost
I have seen a number of Civics with gills grafted on their fenders and E36 M3 mirrors screwed on their doors. There are even E36 318's with gills on their fenders.

I think OEM gills look tacky for the most part and aftermarket are abominations.


tangotango - 11/27/2008 10:31:32 PM
0 Boost
Buick used "Port Holes" to indicate the number of cylinders under the bonnet. 3 portholes per side indicated 3 cylinders per side, ie, V6. 4 holes per side indicated 4 cylinders per side, ie V8. The portholes were a fitting design trait because Buick always thought of itself as what yachts would be like if they grew wheels. Well...translate yacht to boat and then carry on with the negative cannotation that has with cars and then you can form your own opinion. LOL. As for the rest of them, let them have their day. Some people seem to like the look so much they afix aftermarket ones to their own cars. Oh well..I guess it takes all types...


AE86AE86 - 11/29/2008 6:57:34 PM
+1 Boost
I guess people have just lost interest in Buicks! (I never had any, aside from the 87 GNX)


answeranswer - 11/27/2008 11:29:06 PM
+2 Boost
The BMW style things don't bother me.

It's those stupid aftermarket Buick/Maserati style portholes that are getting on my nerves.

I've seem them pop up on everything from Accords to F150s.

Stop the madness!


BMWSLSMNBMWSLSMN - 11/27/2008 11:52:34 PM
0 Boost
No NEED whatsoever to bash BMW here. I know BMW didn't invent and defintely were not the first to put the plastic gills on their cars. This article isn't written by BMW, so bash the writer not the product.

It's amazing how people will use any chance to get to bash BMW. Must be a sign of envy!


AE86AE86 - 11/28/2008 1:25:28 AM
+1 Boost
Did you read the article? It doesn't just bash BMW for introducing ugly, non-functional styling cues, it questions the rest of the industry for blindly adding these useless styling cues.


M53RM53R - 11/29/2008 6:23:35 AM
+1 Boost
Check out the fender gills on the new Infinite FX!


AE86AE86 - 11/29/2008 9:06:28 PM
+1 Boost
Yes, they suck


MunichRobMunichRob - 11/29/2008 8:09:08 PM
+1 Boost
Aston Martin has "fender gills" on all it's models & has had on many models throughout its history. I think they really made it hot.


Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC