Give Me A Break! Are These Really The Most Recommended Cars In The US?

Give Me A Break! Are These Really The Most Recommended Cars In The US?

Who do you go to for advice when buying a new car?  What about owners themselves?  AutoPacific has just analyzed recommendation intentions from 25,000 new-car owners, and the results offer interesting insights.

AutoPacific, which has provided automotive analysis to carmakers since 1986, bases its findings on a just-completed comprehensive survey of more than 25,000 consumers who purchased or leased new cars or light trucks in the period from September to December 2008.

“Typically, car buyers are very pleased when they first drive their new car off the dealer lot. But just as a vehicle’s worth depreciates over time, some car owners’ level of confidence depreciates,” says George Peterson, president of AutoPacific. “We have quantified their level of confidence to see which new car owners will recommend their model most and this is information which will help new car shoppers make informed, confident buying decisions. While many owners can be happy with their new cars, it takes another level of confidence to recommend it.”

Porsche leads as the top brand in a close race, with the highest owner recommendation of 91%. “Porsche owners’ feelings for their cars run deep, some might call it devotion,” says Peterson. “Clearly that is still the case as the Porsche line-up all scored well in this survey.”

The vehicle - car or truck - registering highest overall satisfaction in 2009 is the Infiniti G37, which was recommended by 95% of new owners.  The truck with the highest overall satisfaction score is the Ford F-150 recommended by 89% of its owners. In a tie, the SUVs with the highest overall satisfaction score are the GMC Yukon XL and Honda CR-V recommended by 93% of their owners.

At the manufacturer level, multiple top-ranked award winners include: Toyota with eight top rankings (Toyota 6, Lexus 2), Ford with six (Ford 5, Lincoln 1), Honda with three, General Motors with two (Chevy 1, GMC 1), and Chrysler with two (Jeep 1, Dodge 1).

AutoPacific’s research objectively measures owner recommendations with newly purchased or leased passenger cars or light trucks by ranking new owners’ responses to the question “Would you recommend your new vehicle to a friend or relative? Scores are based on the responses, ranging from “Yes, definitely,” “Yes, with reservations,” or “No.”

BRAND: Porsche

PASSENGER CARS:
Premium Luxury Car                            Lexus LS
Executive Luxury Car                           Jaguar XF
Aspirational Luxury Car                        Infiniti G37 (most recommended – 95%)
Large Car                                            Toyota Avalon
Luxury Mid-Size Car                             Lexus ES
Premium Mid-Size Car                         Toyota Camry
Mid-Size Car                                       Volkswagen Jetta
Image Compact Car                             Toyota Prius
Mainstream Compact Car                     Subaru Impreza
Economy Car                                       Honda Fit
Premium Sports Car                             Chevrolet Corvette
Sports Car                                           Nissan 350Z
Sporty Car                                           Ford Mustang

LIGHT TRUCKS:
Large Light-Duty Pickup                       Ford F-150
Large Heavy-Duty Pickup                     Ford F-Super Duty
Compact Pickup                                  Toyota Tacoma
Luxury Sport Utility                              Lincoln Navigator
Large Sport Utility                                GMC Yukon XL
Premium Mid-Size Sport Utility             Toyota 4Runner
Mid-Size Sport Utility                           Dodge Nitro
Compact SUV/Off-Road Vehicle            Jeep Wrangler
Luxury Crossover SUV                         Land Rover LR2
Large Crossover SUV                           Ford Flex
Premium Mid-Size Crossover SUV        Ford Edge
Mainstream Mid-Size Crossover SUV    Honda CR-V
Compact Crossover SUV                      Honda Element
Minivan                                               Toyota Sienna


Soon, AutoPacific will announce its 13th annual Vehicle Satisfaction Awards.  The VSA establishes numerical satisfaction ratings for virtually every passenger car and light truck in the North American market. Owner satisfaction is measured across 48 specific areas related to a vehicle's operation, comfort, safety and the overall purchase/lease experience. The 2009 ratings reflect input from buyers and lessees of new vehicles acquired September through December 2008.


2009 BimmerFest Photo Gallery

2010 Mercedes-Benz E-Class Photo Gallery


If you want to see your photos running on our homepage photo ticker, be sure to upload your photos on the go by sending them to Mobile@AutoSpies.com

There are photos and then there are AutoSpies.com photos!


Share on Facebook



AgentOrangeAgentOrange - 5/12/2009 4:26:07 PM
-16 Boost
All this shows is that average American doen't know shit.


david999david999 - 5/12/2009 4:38:12 PM
+7 Boost

No BMW, Mercedes or Audi? A little surprising that not one of their vehicles is on this list near the top.


Agent009Agent009 - 5/12/2009 4:42:12 PM
+1 Boost
Well those Dodge Nitro owners must have been louder...


BremboBrembo - 5/12/2009 8:24:12 PM
+10 Boost
Not happy because your brand is not on the list.


dlindlin - 5/13/2009 3:23:32 AM
+8 Boost
Give me a break! Other than BMW placement maketing, this shit, no, site, has to resort to flame war for attracting visitor?

Anyway, maybe quality is and should be more important than you think other than brand image. This past week the windshield water nozzle on my 3 suddenly stop working. C'mon! I barely used it to start with. Guess $300 will be gone.

Long live the flame war......


kablaamkablaam - 5/13/2009 1:42:42 PM
-1 Boost
Dlin:

WHy did you even buy a 3 series if it's such a horrible vehicle? Do you not do your DD before you slap down 40+k on a purchase?

Who's the sucker?

P.S. I've had 3 BMW's with no problems, not one.


dlindlin - 5/13/2009 4:08:10 PM
+2 Boost
Read my words, did I say it's a horrible car? Initial quality is of ocurse good, but after 45K miles it starts to give me some glitch out of nowhere. Not a big one, just several hundred each time. Last one is window regulation system, and the one before is stereo system.

Just wait, it'll get to you..... :)


VISOVISO - 5/13/2009 4:17:58 PM
-1 Boost
David999 refer to the post above you. American's obssession with Lexus severly hinders them from getting any automotive respect around the world.


fourmccsfourmccs - 5/12/2009 4:41:54 PM
+1 Boost
You really need to get a grip. This is nothing more than a opinion generated by gathered data that is sure to be biased one way or another. Just like you and me. Nothing important in the big picture.


david999david999 - 5/12/2009 4:44:39 PM
0 Boost

Remember, david969 is a troll.


91z4me91z4me - 5/12/2009 11:16:29 PM
+5 Boost
How about both of you davids pull your lips over your head and swallow?


MrBratwurstMrBratwurst - 5/13/2009 4:49:30 AM
+3 Boost
— fourmccs:

| This is nothing more than a opinion generated
| by gathered data that is sure to be biased one
| way or another.

The larger the dataset the less likely it is to be biased.


| Just like you and me. Nothing important in the big picture.

This list is exactly the big picture.


holmstarholmstar - 5/13/2009 8:55:52 AM
-1 Boost
No, it would be easy to produce a large yet very biased data set. You really need to take a good look at their methods in order to determine the degree of bias, if any. The quantity of data means nothing.


MrBratwurstMrBratwurst - 5/13/2009 9:35:32 AM
+2 Boost
— holmstar:

No, it would be easy to produce a large yet very biased data set.

"Given a random variable with a finite expected value, if its values are repeatedly sampled, as the number of these observations increases, their mean will tend to approach and stay close to the expected value (the average for the population)."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_large_numbers

See also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monte_Carlo_method - an application of this theorem


| You really need to take a good look at their methods
| in order to determine the degree of bias, if any.

True, but I bet they tried to minimize bias as much as they can.


holmstarholmstar - 5/13/2009 1:51:25 PM
0 Boost
You a presuming that their sample truly is random, when that is NEVER the case in realty. The only way you could have a random sample if is you were able to force every person you try contact to be available, and that they will be willing to talk to you. The fact that this is not the case itself will add some unknown bias to your study. Sampling methods are a huge issue.

You also assume that it was the intent of the organization that was conducting the study to produce an unbiased result. It is certainly possible that this is not the case.


david969isAFooldavid969isAFool - 5/15/2009 12:12:39 AM
+1 Boost
David969 - you're so deluded in your vision of lexus, solid car but no soul, don't assume everyone believes in your view of their products.


Joe_LimonJoe_Limon - 5/12/2009 5:21:46 PM
+4 Boost
Good for Ford! You'll be number 1 soon when/if GM/Chrysler dies and you keep up the competitive products.


Joe_LimonJoe_Limon - 5/13/2009 11:30:44 AM
+4 Boost
In a market where 95% of automotive companies are "bleeding cash", yes... yes they should be proud.


PerformanceGuyPerformanceGuy - 5/12/2009 5:37:26 PM
+2 Boost
Like every list, some cars belong there and others don't. I have to agree there are and abnormal amount of Toyota's on the list, but good to see Nissan and Infiniti on the list, they are amazing cars.


veyron1001veyron1001 - 5/12/2009 5:55:17 PM
-1 Boost
The mustang a sports car? Wow not even close. The last time I checked a stage 2 cobalt interior upgrade for the camaro is not premium.


pagemanpageman - 5/12/2009 6:08:21 PM
0 Boost
Good list. Not many "so called" North American product. Lexus & Toyota lead the way again. "HELLO DETROIT!!!!!", the world says "WAKE UP !!!!"

I agree with the list less the Mustang. what a P.O.S.



Type707Type707 - 5/12/2009 6:19:12 PM
+1 Boost
Does it really matter?


Joe_LimonJoe_Limon - 5/12/2009 6:57:15 PM
+5 Boost
This is the advice from other people. It was a survey.


trungdqtrungdq - 5/12/2009 7:19:49 PM
-7 Boost
Toyota and Lexus are falling faster than others. Q1 loss = 6.9 billion => It's a fact. It means that in reality people don't want to follow this recommendation.


AnthonyAnthony - 5/12/2009 11:32:07 PM
+4 Boost
That's because they were already selling faster than others. This means that you are a dope.


Yonder7Yonder7 - 5/12/2009 8:15:28 PM
-2 Boost
The people that knows about cars is always a minority..so of course you won´t see Mercedes Benz there, For the price of an S65 you can buy almost 2 LS460. If you are talking about mass consumed cars, this list is not so bad....but definitely not correct.


XYZZXYZZ - 5/13/2009 8:15:13 AM
+3 Boost
maybe the S-class is not raved over so much by OWNERS as mere aspirants as you? last year CR could recommend NOT A SINGLE benz product, due to reliability issues.

they have improved since however, with 5 of 12 MB models now recommended.

meanwhile, lexus gets 6 of 8 models recommended. (with the LS getting a 99 rating on their road test evaluation.) and toyota, 11 out of 16.

the population of vehicles underlying CR's survey is some 1,400,000.


holmstarholmstar - 5/13/2009 8:59:36 AM
+1 Boost
That there are relatively few MB owners does not mean that MB would fall lower in the list. The list is based on average owner satisfaction, thus it doesn't matter whether you have 100 or 10000 owners of a specific car.


Agent00RAgent00R - 5/12/2009 9:00:08 PM
-2 Boost
I would categorize these results as good advice for the average consumer that needs a car to get from point "A" to point "B".

None of the cars have a tremendous amount of soul but they do the job they're designed to do; drive and be reliable.


91z4me91z4me - 5/12/2009 11:19:22 PM
+1 Boost
Yeah that Mustang has no soul. Or Corvette or Imprezza (WRX or STI) for that matter.

I mean if the Corolla isn't on there it can't be a good list.


sectorsector - 5/12/2009 11:06:59 PM
+6 Boost
Nice comprehensive list, you'd only wan't to go german if you got cash cow in the back yard... or don't mind burning some cash for vanity.


AnthonyAnthony - 5/12/2009 11:34:18 PM
+1 Boost
These are recommended for value, not status. The latter being subjective seeing as most people without a stick up their ass view Lexus as a brand on par with Mercedes and BMW, and Toyota on par with Volkswagen for examples.


holmstarholmstar - 5/13/2009 9:08:00 AM
-1 Boost
I'm so tired of the astroturfing that goes on here. I wonder how many fanboys are actually astroturfers (employees of their preferred brand, paid to post messages on forums/comments sections)

*sigh*


VISOVISO - 5/13/2009 4:21:20 PM
0 Boost
Anyone who views Lexus on par with MB, Audi, and BMW has as stick up their butt already and needs to remove it. When Lexus can match these in technology, racing, etc. then they it may have a chance. At least the Chinese prefer Buick over Lexus.


AnthonyAnthony - 5/13/2009 11:42:10 PM
+2 Boost
I'm glad you view technology and racing and such as the rulers for measurement as to what makes a luxury brand. When Audi, MB and BMW can match Lexus in terms of reliability and dealership service get back to me. Oh, and America preferred Lexus to Audi since Lexus's second year in existance (and still to this day). Lexus AND Buick have better quality and reliability than Audi, MB and BMW though, so go figure.


91z4me91z4me - 5/14/2009 10:43:20 AM
+1 Boost
That was extremely obvious sarcasm. I am sorry you missed it.


M53RM53R - 5/13/2009 6:56:34 AM
+5 Boost
Dodge Nitro... lol


lexusrox123lexusrox123 - 5/13/2009 8:54:42 AM
+3 Boost
thats exactly what i thought...


OblivObliv - 5/13/2009 1:27:29 PM
+1 Boost
Definitley got the Mustang right. Anyone who drives one knows, which is exactly why its on this survey :P

Anyone who disagrees is simply jealous or ignorant.


KrazeedddKrazeeddd - 5/14/2009 3:09:37 PM
+2 Boost
Even if Nitro/Mustang/whatever.. owners may be complete idiots, so what? They would recomend their car to a friend and people take that responability pretty seriously. More than 3 owners. More than S class owners - deal with it. It has meaning. The fact that the well informed group here would never have bought a particular car to begin with is the irrelevant fact.


Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC