Consumer Reports Gives The All-New Toyota Camry A Nod And Slights The Passat

Consumer Reports Gives The All-New Toyota Camry A Nod And Slights The Passat
The mid-size sedan battle continues to heat up.

Toyota's all-new Camry is the perennial sales king in this crowd but with pressure from Hyundai's Sonata and Volkswagen's all-new Passat, Toyota clearly stepped up its game. So much so that Consumer Reports gave it a recommendation. Considering Consumer Report's tougher stance lately -- particularly with Honda -- and the highly competitive market for mid-size sedans, this should be considered an achievement.

But as the Camry gains momentum, the all-new Volkswagen Passat slowed down. Though its hot off the heels of a Motor Trend 2012 Car of the Year nod, the Passat didn't make such an impactful dent with the Consumer Reports crowd.

An interesting element to note about the Passat TDI is that the EPA estimates it can achieve 31/43, city/highway; however, Car and Driver reportedly received 45 mpg on a long trip from Ann Arbor, MI to Long Island, NY. And Motor Trend reported 34.3 mpg in an automatic Passat TDI. I bring this up since Consumer Reports mentions the Camry Hybrid achieved an "amazing" 38 mpg, meanwhile the TDI racked up 37 mpg overall and 51 mpg on the highway, which seems to be downplayed.

Maybe the Toyota is that good?

The way things are shaping up, it looks like we could have an all-new battle between diesels and hybrids. Remember the Jetta TDI vs. Prius fight that everyone discussed a couple years back? Can you say "do over?"


Consumer Reports has picked what it believes is the best family sedan: It's the 2012 Toyota Camry Hybrid.

Though few observers were particular bowled over by the new Camry's less-than-bold looks, Consumer Reports found a lot of practical considerations. "The Camry has a nicer interior, more responsive handling, and better fuel economy than previous models," the magazine says in a statement. And the gas mileage in the hybrid? an "amazing" 38 miles a gallon...

...Among other models, Consumer Reports wasn't as kind to the Volkswagen Passat, which it says has "grown larger and softer." It doesn't handle as well and the interior seems more ordinary compared to previous Passats. Fuel economy is ordinary except on the diesel version, which managed "an excellent" 37 mpg overall and 51 mpg on the highway. Passat is Motor Trend's Car of the Year and is a candidate for the coveted North American Car of the Year...


Read Article

knowitall1985knowitall1985 - 1/2/2012 3:46:44 PM
+5 Boost
Toyota is better quality than a V-dud any day.....


FromThePassengerSeatFromThePassengerSeat - 1/2/2012 9:48:56 PM
0 Boost
Build quality, yes. But any VW (except possibly the new Jetta) will offer a higher-quality driving experience than its Toyota rival. Passat>Camry, Golf>Corolla, and Eos>Solara, at least from an enthusiast's standpoint.


atc98092atc98092 - 1/2/2012 4:24:48 PM
+1 Boost
Sorry, I'll take my VW before any Toyota. Not saying anyone else has to. That's just my personal taste. And that's what is great about the USA, everyone is entitled to their opinion. Too bad some people make it a priority to bash anyone with different opinions.


atc98092atc98092 - 1/3/2012 8:32:40 AM
+1 Boost
See, I knew this would happen. I voice my opinion, and make it known that it was only an opinion. Still, the deboosters go rampant. The commenters here can't seem to accept that people are entitled to their opinion, and that personal feelings are just that: it's the way they feel. I don't trash other people's choices, but you can't seem to allow me the same courtesy...


MonopolyMonopoly - 1/3/2012 11:58:25 PM
+1 Boost
@atc98092

My personal take is that VW automobiles truly suck. However, do I agree with your overall viewpoint. But don't worry too much about Autospies members as many are a passionate bunch who take their (and others) opinions, ideas or thoughts seriously, sometimes to the extreme! Lol!


knowitall1985knowitall1985 - 1/2/2012 4:33:43 PM
+5 Boost
It's not an opinion it's fact. Toyota has had better quality for years. So take your v-dub and learn the hard way. Problems with bad reasale value and crummy dealers with poor service. It's your money. You'll learn!! Maybe!!! Some people never learn....


atc98092atc98092 - 1/2/2012 4:51:48 PM
+1 Boost
Again, your opinion. I've had VWs for years. Yes, there were some quality issues with my 2002 Jetta (coil packs, window clips), but my 06 was fine, as is my '11 Tiguan. My 03 Passat has also been trouble-free. Still have it, although it's fairly low mileage with only around 55,000.

Again, simply my experiences. Your mileage may vary. I also have a fantastic dealer. Yes, they do exist. But don't tell me what I have to drive, or how I should feel about them.


knowitall1985knowitall1985 - 1/2/2012 6:20:47 PM
+5 Boost
It's fact survey's show vw breaks more than Toyota. I could give a crap less what u drive. I admire your loyalty. Toyota is still a better quality product....


LJ745LJ745 - 1/2/2012 6:44:54 PM
-1 Boost
Until recently, when it came to amenities, fit, finish, and handling, Toyota could not hold a candle to VW. Yes, they had more maintenance issues, but the driving experience was heads and tails above Toyota. What VW has "sold out" on by "Americanizing" is their heritage. Now they are just another Toyota with nothing special to offer. This is the reason I have kept my 2004 Jetta rather than buy either of the most recent models. They just aren't the same. You want an appliance? Then buy Toyota. You want to smile when you drive? Buy VW (at least it used to be that way).


FromThePassengerSeatFromThePassengerSeat - 1/2/2012 9:45:01 PM
0 Boost
Who cares what CR thinks? They, thinking of cars as appliances, care little about whether a car has a soul (i.e. the Camry doesn't). CR is run by non-enthusiasts who are guaranteed to disagree with us car buffs on many counts.


FromThePassengerSeatFromThePassengerSeat - 1/3/2012 12:50:15 AM
+1 Boost
"The People" are those who buy not cars, but appliances such as the Camry, an incredibly dull (even in "sporty" SE trim) loaf of Wonder Bread.


MercedesSLMercedesSL - 1/3/2012 8:12:31 AM
+4 Boost
+1 VW and fun to drive do not go together...they drive nice, but are not fun.


WillisWillis - 1/3/2012 12:14:14 PM
-1 Boost
"Fun" is subjective.

I've owned VWs in the past and I thought they drove much better than their rivals. My sister drives the new Jetta TDI which I sampled, I thought it was a fun machine, especially the way the engine hauled butt.


knowitall1985knowitall1985 - 1/3/2012 10:43:23 AM
+1 Boost
Fun=Noisy tin can...


LexSucksLexSucks - 1/3/2012 4:56:37 PM
+1 Boost
Toyota Camry = Best car ever built


Designer1Designer1 - 1/3/2012 5:08:50 PM
+1 Boost
I have to say the new Camry is ugly compared to the previous generation, and its material quality is also cheaper. Unfortunately, but I think Toyota is taking its cars into the wrong direction. They need to bring the old good quality back and add on top of it fun to drive factor.


Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC