Why ONE Man Isn't Excited For The All-New BMW M5

Why ONE Man Isn't Excited For The All-New BMW M5
Though I may have just posted Top Gear's review of the all-new BMW M5, in which Richard Hammond says the vehicle is "...the best car in the world right now," I told you that for every cheerleader there would be a naysayer.

Well, I have found him.

James Wong might not exactly be a household name, like Hammond, but he does make some valid points about the new F10 M car. What it has increased in horsepower, it has also increased in size and heft. In addition, the new dual-clutch 'box is the only option for the time being; however, we will see a row-it-yourself coming stateside.

All of these reasons are good points to be skeptical about.

Personally, knowing that the exhaust note is artificially being piped through the sound system is just the lamest thing on the planet for a "driver's car," but what do I know?

Anyhow, Wong's argument is plain and simple: power doesn't equate to an awesome car as there are plenty of other critical attributes that make a driver's car just that.

Do YOU agree or disagree? That is the question...

...These days, numbers no longer do the talking...

...It has a score sheet that would make any school teacher proud – 552bhp, 680Nm of torque, 0-100mph in 8 seconds and a comfortable top speed in excess of 300km/h. However, like the old adage that top scoring students are not necessarily the ones who would make the most of their life in the future, there are as many reasons why the M5 doesn’t tickle my senses as much as it should...


Read Article

WillisWillis - 3/12/2012 11:31:11 PM
+1 Boost
Cars will continue to get heavier despite all the weight saving techniques because buyers expect all these useless features that they'll never use (but hey, bragging rights are everything) and just add more weight.

Also, cars are moving up in terms of classes. On many BMW forums the consensus is that the 1 series is the new 3er, the 3er is the new 5er and the 5er is a new 7er and the 7er is...well, a 7er with some additional qualities.


JRobUSCJRobUSC - 3/13/2012 2:43:08 AM
+13 Boost
The author of that article lost all credibility is his "review" when he said "I have to qualify that I haven't actually driven the new M5". Or did you miss that part?

Sorry, but you can't review a restaurant without eating the food, and you can't review the drive of a car without, you know, driving it. Kind of an important step.


Agent00RAgent00R - 3/13/2012 7:50:44 AM
-1 Boost
@JRob

I think YOU actually missed the point.

This isn't a REVIEW. This is simply an editorial of one man's thoughts about a product.

No he hasn't driven it, but that's not the point of the piece.


JRobUSCJRobUSC - 3/13/2012 9:11:07 AM
+5 Boost
Agent00R, NO, I didn't. Take a moment and read the article. You'll notice he makes deductions about the drive of the M5 by basing it on the time he has spent driving the regular F10 5-Series, and then he turns around and uses those deductions as validations for his preconceived opinions. How about actually driving it first? Crazy idea, I know. He may find out he was right, he may find out he was wrong, but at the very least, he'd FIND OUT. And THEN he can report on it.


david999david999 - 3/13/2012 12:20:32 PM
+4 Boost
JRobUSC is correct. No credibility for the writer commenting without actually driving the vehicle.


dlindlin - 3/13/2012 11:33:20 AM
+1 Boost
The author is looking at the wrong brand. Don't complain about BMW not being a Porsche.


BondMI6BondMI6 - 3/13/2012 12:36:09 PM
+4 Boost
Totally agree JRob.

No drive- no review.

That being said, any weight issues the F10 has will be reduced substantially as the next gen 5er will have a sig amount of CF and should reduce weight by at least 400/500 lbs....

-Bond


Car4LifeCar4Life - 3/13/2012 2:16:51 PM
+1 Boost
One letter, two numbers...E-6-3...best complete package.


CarCrazedinCaliCarCrazedinCali - 3/14/2012 1:03:55 PM
+2 Boost
seems to me the E63 still regularly trails the M5 in terms of being the best drivers car


aboodestaaboodesta - 3/14/2012 11:16:59 AM
+1 Boost
The problem with the M5 is that the 5 series it was built upon didn't take advantage of the new weight saving techniques that were used in the new 1 and 3 series as it was already in testing phase so it was too late. I expect the next generation 5 series to be significantly lighter. That being said, its still an amazing car. If you have any doubts, just check its lap times compared to the old lighter one. It kills it!


Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC