VIDEO: Has The Purist's BMW M5 Become Just The OPPOSITE?

VIDEO: Has The Purist's BMW M5 Become Just The OPPOSITE?
As the years pass by and technology continues to progress across all industries, we've seen some major paradigm shifts. In the automotive industry, the shift -- no pun intended -- is the move from standard gearboxes to new-age automated manual transmissions.

First it was "F1" transmissions, then it was single-clutch sequential manuals, and now it has come to the dual-clutch 'boxes.

While many folks have embraced the new automated manuals, and automakers are actually ceasing to produce do-it-yourself transmissions, we're left counting down how many vehicles are left with a "stick"

Personally, I love them. To me, there's a time and place for a dual-clutch transmission and that's at the track.

But one of Motor Trend's reviewers seems to think otherwise. While driving the all-new BMW M5 with a "stick," he points out that vehicles of this caliber with standards feel clumsy and all around it doesn't seem to gel. To us it's pretty clear he concludes that it really is fit for the high-tech, dual-clutch transmission.

That being said, we have to ask:

Has BMW's new M5 been dumbed down by the manual transmission, or is that just a cop-out line said by posers that want to pretend they're Michael Schumacher and in a race car?


This week on Ignition, Carlos Lago revisits the BMW M5 to test out something that was missing from the first test: a manual transmission. Is the 6-speed stick shift better than the standard automatic twin-clutch version?



Read Article

PUGPROUDPUGPROUD - 11/15/2012 8:11:41 AM
+3 Boost
I personally love a manual but I admit I'm old school. High technology cars are no longer a collection of component parts but more total systems talking to each other and working seamlessly (often with no driver input) with each other. The driving force (pun) is to eliminate any human input or involvement. We are headed full steam ahead toward a world one day when no human involement will be necessary and no one will need to or know how to drive. Car enthusiasts (people who like to actually drive in the traditional sense) will be viewed as outcasts, old timers, a threat to others' safety and environmentally insensitive.


irishmikeirishmike - 11/15/2012 11:09:50 AM
0 Boost
I think I will always want the old fashioned manual. Those who prefer the auto-box are maybe in more dense traffic situations on a frequent basis. Their choice is partially out of practicality.
BMW has always been at the top of the heap as far as having the most fun to drive manual shifts.


CarCrazedinCaliCarCrazedinCali - 11/15/2012 1:27:05 PM
+1 Boost
I have found that the joy of driving for ME has nothing to do with shifting a gearbox. I think (without having driven the new M5) that it is very likely more refined and less of a hardcore drivers car... Enough complaining about that fact will probably produce a more purist BMW model, maybe that's what the 1M is...


85bmw745i85bmw745i - 11/18/2012 3:13:48 AM
+1 Boost
I'll row my own gears thank you


Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC