DEBATE: Should Electric And Hybrid Vehicles Face A Tax?

DEBATE: Should Electric And Hybrid Vehicles Face A Tax?
Interesting timing of this to become a hot news item with the Tesla Model S racking up sales. In the past couple of weeks it seems that there's an issue for electric and hybrid vehicles that is bubbling to the surface.

As I am sure most of you know, gasoline is taxed. Of course the more you use, the more you're effectively forking over the government and, theoretically, it should help deter folks from getting gas guzzlers. The reality is people don't care and see it as the cost of "doing business." People want to have fun, whether that's in a supercar or a monster truck.

Of course because electric and hybrid vehicles use less fuel, or none at all, folks are starting to push forward the concept of taxing electric and hybrid vehicles. A part of me finds this to be an admirable idea; however, the concept of adding a percentage-based tax on top of a more fuel efficient vehicle is simply wrong.

Consumer Reports polled its users via a social media platform and soon enough they were receiving some great answers. Obviously, some folks were pissed by the idea of an additional tax slapped on. Others weren't fazed. Lastly, there were some shockingly good ideas to spread fairness:

1) Why not tax tires? Everyone's got those!

2) If we're going to tax due to road damage, the best way to do it would be to tax vehicles based on their weight. I am sure someone in D.C. would lobby it destroys the trucking industry, which I am sure it would make more challenging.

3) The simplest method would be to increase fees/taxes on drivers' licenses, registrations and plates.

All of that said, we're curious: what say you?

Should electric or hybrid vehicles get another tax slapped on?

Read Article

jeffgalljeffgall - 5/17/2013 1:59:25 AM
+1 Boost
Why not start by removing the current tax credit? Oh wait, then no one would buy these in a fair market.


ErnestHouseErnestHouse - 5/17/2013 4:34:25 AM
+1 Boost
None of this is George Bush's fault. Stop wasting so much money in government so less of my paycheck has to be taken away. We could start with the $16 muffins then move to not hiring IRS agents to harass companies and individuals the President disagrees with.


ParadoXParadoX - 5/17/2013 8:46:09 AM
+4 Boost
I am supposed to believe an article written by a Republican politician with no scientific credentials? Most of the "research" against global climate change comes from lobby groups, think tanks, and other institutes associated with big business and energy companies.

EV's are a good thing in terms of performance (all that torque), lowering dependence on oil resources, etc. The produces just need to work on lowering the price and extending range.

That said, they should figure out what the average gasoline tax drivers pay and use that as a road tax.


monstermonster - 5/17/2013 10:36:59 AM
+3 Boost
There is nothing to figure out. I pay tax on the electricity I use. Get the tax redistributed to the different department. On top of that Fix the Damn roads. Do some work first before asking for more money. Beggars


vdivvdiv - 5/17/2013 10:09:18 AM
+1 Boost
Why not tax all vehicles based on their road usage similar to what tolls do for passenger vehicles and trucks? What is wrong with using the miles driven and the weight of the vehicle to determine a portion of the registration fee at the time of renewal (i.e. once a year) then using a portion of that tax for the interstates.

Taxing gasoline is not fair for vehicles or motorized equipment that do not use the roads, such as for farming or landscaping.

Taxing electric vehicles at rates much higher than the equivalent gasoline tax is also not fair.


Agent009Agent009 - 5/17/2013 10:16:34 AM
+1 Boost
IMHO. EV and Hybrids should pay an additional registration tax. Due to their inherent nature they are off the grid or minimally on the grid as far as road taxes go. They still need to pay fair share of road taxes based on the mileage or a flat rate fee. There are still gas savings there to benefit the owner.


MorePowerMorePower - 5/17/2013 4:15:28 PM
+1 Boost
Eliminate the tax credit, eliminate the HOV/Carpool lane 1 passenger allowance and partner with local business to install more EV charging sites.


MezgerMezger - 5/18/2013 7:18:01 AM
+2 Boost
Here in the Netherlands, gasoline is at 1.70 EUR per liter. Most of it is tax. You are also taxed based on how heavy your car is and how much co2 is produced. For example a mid sized diesel sedan costs about 600 EUR per quarter in road taxes. EV & hybrid cars are practically tax free here for good reason. The amount of co2 per kw is much much lower than the co2 coming out of a ICE and the amount of electricity that will be produced in the future will come from Nuclear energy. This is very important as rising sea levels impacts our lives directly. To those who say this is a myth, please come over and see how we fight rising water everyday. Plus with 500 mile batteries being developed, I say keep all the incentives rolling. I bike a LOT because private transportation is so expensive.


Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC