REVIEW: 2015 Audi A3. Zooming Ahead In The New Sub $30k Segment Or Now Following?

REVIEW: 2015 Audi A3. Zooming Ahead In The New Sub $30k Segment Or Now Following?
Palo Alto, California. 2015 Audi A3 product launch- It's a pretty regular occurrence to see Audi knocking the ball out of the park these last few years. It seems they can do nothing wrong saleswise and customer impressions have reflected their strategic and tactical decisions.

 

 

So when we got the call to test the all new 2015 Audi A3 we anticipated brilliance.
2015 Audi A3 Full Photo Gallery




Some quick facts about this all new ride:

 

• The A3 Sedan sets new standards in the entry premium market, including the first-ever 4G LTE data connection?• Audi showcases progressive technology, craftsmanship and performance with the Audi A3 ?• Over the next 16 months, Audi will roll out the complete A3 family, including the A3 Cabriolet, A3 TDI clean diesel, S3 and A3 e-tron® PHEV 

 

The base MSRP for the Audi A3 1.8 TFSI will start at $29,900 and the 2.0 TFSI® will start at $32,900.

 

The A3 Sedan brings to the entry premium market new innovative technologies and the detailed craftsmanship found in larger flagship Audi sedans. The Audi A3 Sedan features standard leather seating surfaces and exceptional ergonomics, and offers the signature Singleframe® grille, ultra-thin retractable MMI® display, available Audi drive select, 4G LTE connectivity and Bang & Olufsen® audio. The A3 Sedan will also come equipped standard with a panorama glass sunroof and bi-xenon headlights. 

 

In addition to the base premium package, two iconic Audi luxury packages are offered on the A3 Sedan – Premium plus and Prestige. Premium plus will include exclusive 18" 10-spoke-design Audi wheels, an aluminum interior package, and keyless entry for an additional $2,550. The Prestige package will include everything that is offered in premium plus, and will give the A3 Sedan a sportier look with the S Line® exterior kit. It will also offer the Driver Assistance package, Bang & Olufsen Sound System, Audi MMI navigation plus, Audi connect®, Convenience package and full LED headlights for $8,450. 

 

The first impression when you see it in person is that it reminds you of the A4 from a few generations ago in size and stature.

 

But with a fresher exterior and interior design.

 

It is a handsome, conservative car and is no doubt an Audi when it drives by you on the road.



 



Our drive took us from Palo Alto through the twisties all the way to Half Moon Bay then onto Santa Cruz (Home of the Doobie Brothers for the rockers out there). 

 

I found the drive, power and handling to be excellent and almost on par with the arch enemy BMW. The A3 felt light and nimble, with good balance. That's the way like we like it at AutoSpies.com.

 

Gas mileage on the 2.0 was decent getting close to 30mpg on the highway and 24mpg in mixed driving during our short time over two days with the car.

 

I drove the 1.8, but did not spend enough time in it to get an accurate reading on real world mileage. But I did drive it enough to know if you buy one you'll want the 2.0.

 

I just like the feel and balance of the 2.0 for my taste.

 

One of the attributes of the new A3 that Audi is touting is the key tech advancements.

 

Here are some of those highlights:

 

• Most advanced version of Audi connect® including read aloud Facebook® and Twitter® alerts, access to more than 7,000 Internet broadcast stations, RSS news feeds and more. 

• The MMI navigation plus uses 4G LTE to deliver the tailored services of Audi connect to the driver – from navigation with Google Earth and Google Street View to Audi and online traffic information.

• Audi connect® services, such as, text-to-speech function for e-mail and a dictation function for text messages (SMS). 

• An accompanying mobile app will allow advanced functionality between the MMI system and smartphones, passengers will be able to view high-definition videos and make video conference calls from the vehicle. 

• Audi and AT&T have teamed to offer U.S. Audi drivers the expected first-ever in-vehicle 4G LTE data connection.

 

On the inside, it's typical Audi although I found it quite plain all around compared to some of their other interiors.



I guess with a starting price under $30k, cuts had to be made somewhere.

 

And if BMW can get away with stark, basic interiors in their lower models why can't Audi?

 

I'd just ask their interior designers to go look at a KIA Optima with the quilted stitched seats, cabin ergonomics, etc., etc.

 

Here, I'll give them a pass because as a former Apple employee, I appreciate simplicity with purpose. Just don't tell us for that price it can't look more expensive and premium.

 

Front seat interior space works for me at 6'5", but none of the cars in this price range have back seats I'd want to spend any time in.

 

So I know the question you must be asking by now...

 

001, you're being kind and respectful about the A3 but reading in between the lines something was missing and left you cold.

 

If that's what you were thinking, then you are very perceptive and quite right.

 

No matter how hard I tried to find and lock into the 'sizzle' of this new Audi, I just couldn't find it.

 

And in a world where there was no Mercedes CLA exposing such EMOTION and PASSIONATE design to the new customers in this soon to be exploding segment, it wouldn't matter.

 

The new A3 is a very good (not excellent) car. 

 

But see an A3 and CLA driving by you at the same time on the road and our call is MOST people would say the CLA design BLOWS AWAY the A3.

 

It's sexier. It's hotter. And it has the most important element the A3 doesn't.

 

When someone sees a CLA, they INSTANTLY know it's a NEW car. It's different and fresh and like nothing else out there.

 

The Audi A3 on the other hand looks like any other standard Audi (A4, A6).

 

Nothing wrong with that because they're all decent looking but we think this customer is seeking image and recognition.

 

The CLA says hey look at me and my beach body and the A3 says East Coast Brooks Brothers suit.

 

A great example to compare my opinion to is the current iPhone. There is growing dissatisfaction because it's too evolutionary and they've given the competition an opening.

 

Is the iPhone good?

 

Of course, but many are looking for more.

 

Is the A3 good?

 

Yes. But we think after seeing emotional designs like A5, A7…many will be left expecting/wanting more from Audi.

 

They EXPECT Audi to bring the best in everything they do. They expect the line "Never Follow" to mean it. That's what happens once you're champion. Everyone expects it year after year.

To be fair, an Audi executive told us that in 19's and better wheels the car looks much better but those were not ready for the press launch. We'll give them the benefit of the doubt.

 

Will the A3 sell well for Audi?

 

Yes. 

 

Its key flaw though is that Audi has given the competition an opening and it’s looking like Mercedes isn't wasting it.

 

In the end if you're asking who will win this sales/customer perception race and gain key ground in this segment? Three letters my friends. C-L-A.

 

The other interesting thing will be to see who gets the bragging rights of being right on this…AutoSpies.com or Edmunds?

 

They said THIS about A3:

 

Edmunds InsideLine Claims The 2015 Audi A3 Sedan Is Entry-Level Luxury Brilliance and Easily Their Top Pick. Is The Party Over For the Mercedes-Benz CLA?

 

Chime in and tell us who you think has a better take on the situation…Remember the better car doesn’t always win the crown…Who is YOUR money on Spies?




















































2015 Audi A3 Full Photo Gallery




GermanNutGermanNut - 3/16/2014 7:47:36 PM
+1 Boost
The Audi A3 will win the sales race over the Mercedes-Benz CLA for a few key reasons and I believe Edmunds Inside Line was correct in their belief that the A3 Sedan will become the best-selling model vs. the Mercedes-Benz CLA.

1) The A3 holds true to Audi's design philosophy and is instantly recognizable. Not everyone wants the "look at me" styling. Conservative? Sure, but most definitely an Audi.

2) The Mercedes-Benz CLA might look great on the outside, but what about the inside where people spend their time? Many reviews have the interior disappointing and cheap and not up to Mercedes-Benz's usual standard.

3) The Audi A3 Sedan has better technology. You can't get 4G LTE in the CLA.

4) The Audi A3 Sedan comes standard with more equipment than the Mercedes-Benz CLA and is cheaper when optioned similarly. The A3 Sedan comes standard with a panoramic sunroof, leather seating and bi-xenon headlights. Want those options in your CLA? You better have another $5-7K to spend. Not an insignificant amount of money in the $30-35K range.

5) The A3 Sedan has better driving dynamics than the Mercedes-Benz CLA. The CLA might be competent, but it's not as quick, engaging, or sure-footed as the A3 Sedan.

6) The ride in the CLA is extremely harsh. The Mercedes-Benz CLA recently finished last in a Motor Trend comparison test against such competitors as the BMW 320i, Buick Regal and Volkswagen CC due to the cabin shaking and howling over any imperfections like potholes and cracks. The A3 Sedan has a much more comfortable ride, which will count for a lot since these cars are daily drivers.


MattDarringerMattDarringer - 3/16/2014 8:17:24 PM
+1 Boost
The A3 is gorgeous and so not that disco ball horror Mercedes calls the CLA. This has class whereas the CLA is vulgar, vile, and repellent. GO AUDI!


Agent001Agent001 - 3/16/2014 8:42:37 PM
+1 Boost
Excellent points so far. One can also say that people in this segment are more into fashion and flash more than substance.

In the end all that matters are the numbers. Time will tell because the people will vote with their wallets.

001


chewychewy - 3/16/2014 8:47:15 PM
+2 Boost
S Line or some bigger wheels should make a world of difference.


GermanNutGermanNut - 3/16/2014 9:11:59 PM
-1 Boost
The S-line wheels make the A3 sedan look significantly more aggressive and I'm sure when Audi is asked to provide an A3 Sedan for comparison test purposes, it will provide a Premium Plus version with the larger tires and rims.

While that may hurt the A3's ride, I highly doubt it will make the A3's ride as harsh as the CLA's.

Reason number 7 why the A3 Sedan will win is because of the rear seat room. Neither car is spacious by any means for rear seat passengers, but the A3 Sedan does provide more space than the CLA.


cidflekkencidflekken - 3/17/2014 12:35:07 AM
+2 Boost
First, I'd like to congratulate 001 for one of his most objectively balanced reviews.

Secondly, I think the A3 and CLA will appeal to different buyers and both will find success in their own right. I know not many think this, but it's true. The CLA is a stylish, compromised car, by intent, as not to encroach on C-Class sales. The A3 is a roomier, more conservative car, potentially jeopardizing A4 sales, especially with the A4 redesign delayed. Just because two cars are in the same price range, does not mean they can be considered direct competitors. There is 8 inches of difference in rear legroom after all. CLEARLY, Mercedes was not intending for this car to appeal to those looking for and/or needing rear seat space.


gkearns56gkearns56 - 3/17/2014 5:44:11 PM
0 Boost
@BobM: I totally agree with you!!. I personally don't need an over-the-top looking car like that MB CLA. A beautiful, slightly "understated" car is fine with me. When I'm riding in a car, I want the high quality craftsmanship materials and comforts. The MB just isn't doing it for me with the outside front end either, not to mention the interior quality on materials is not up to the normal standard of MB.

I love my current Audi A6 and will stick with my "conservatively" understated Audi's beautiful quality interior. The A3 is a gorgeous piece of machinery and may add one to our family.


Terry989Terry989 - 3/17/2014 4:41:26 PM
+2 Boost
For the US market, does anyone know if this will eventually be offered with a manual option? Maybe in a "IS" or "RS" version?


WelcomeLexusISWelcomeLexusIS - 4/3/2014 11:24:26 PM
+1 Boost
Important clarification is needed here,...The base motor in the A3 is a 1.8 liter turbo making 170 hp. It's performance numbers are slower than the CLA with its own standard 1.8 which makes @201 hp. To go faster, an A3 buyer has to opt up to get the 2.0 which starts at just under $33K and is a few 10ths quicker than the CLA. With the 1.8 liter engine, the A3 gets performance similar, in part, to what you would get in a Jetta or Mazda3. In fact, the A3 shares this base engine with the Jetta starting with the 2015 model. If style, price and performance are your main objectives, the base CLA trumps the base A3. Also, Audi should have done much more to distinguish the styling of the new A3 beyond the soon to be replaced A4.


Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC