Two 20-something Idiots And A Valet's Mistake With A 2014 Ferrari 458 Spider Ends With A Lawsuit

Two 20-something Idiots And A Valet's Mistake With A 2014 Ferrari 458 Spider Ends With A Lawsuit
"Oh boy," is the perfect way to sum up this story.

A lawyer staying in St. Petersburg, Florida for a convention brought his 2014 Ferrari 458 Spider to the show and left it with the valet. One would assume that he tipped well as the car was placed front and center, and that the staff would recognize that its owner was a 73-year-old-man. 

Turns out one early morning a 28-year-old-man, Levi Miles, was trying to impress his 24-year-old date, Chloe Rimmer, when he essentially pressured the valet into giving him the keys to the car. Although Miles didn't know how to drive the vehicle even remotely, he did get it in gear and moving along after some time. 

Unfortunately for Miles and Rimmer, they were stopped not too long after because the rocket scientist didn't know how to turn on the vehicle's lights. That's when police noticed cocaine on the center console and things got really hairy. 

Long story short, Miles didn't technically steal the vehicle because the keys were provided by the valet. The lawyer whose vehicle was released sees things differently as he has filed a lawsuit to remedy the vehicle's diminished value. 

Miles was charged with grand theft of more than $100,000, possession of cocaine and habitually driving with a suspended or revoked license. Rimmer, on the other hand, was only charged with possession of marijuana as a gram of it was discovered in her purse. 


It’s a problem almost no one can relate to: The valet hands the keys to your $300,000 Ferrari to the wrong person.

It happened in July at the Vinoy Renaissance St. Petersburg Resort & Golf Club, according to police, who ended up arresting the man and woman who drove off in it.

Now, the owner of that yellow 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia Spider has filed a lawsuit against the Vinoy and its parking operator, 717 Parking Enterprises.


Read Article

MDarringerMDarringer - 1/28/2018 11:45:07 AM
-2 Boost
I doubt the car has diminished in value, but the owner being compensated for any damage and be treated to a professional detailing for his car by someone who is reputable is an appropriate gesture. Should some financial compensation be given as an "STFU" payoff? Sure.


absentabsent - 1/29/2018 8:46:18 AM
+2 Boost
You are very wrong, this incident is immediately reported on Carfax (as is every service, and every touch up done by the dealer).
Carfax does not provide details, just the fact that it was "stolen and recovered".
Future buyer or dealer taking the car in trade will consider it when valuing the car.
Most will pass on it as no one wants the car with a "record" and the retail value of a car like Ferrari loses at least 30% at minimum.


cidflekkencidflekken - 1/28/2018 4:16:00 PM
+5 Boost
What I love most about this story is that the perp is stating that he didn't "steal" the Ferrari since the valet gave him the keys. Haha. Seriously? He admitted to claiming the Ferrari was his and being a bit rude to the valet in order to get the keys and even lied about where the valet ticket was, knowing full-well it was not his car. That's "stealing", buddy.


STLUCIEAPPRAISALCOSTLUCIEAPPRAISALCO - 1/29/2018 9:31:27 AM
+2 Boost
If there's even a scratch on that car, after repairs it will be worth approximately $50,000.00 less after repairs. The St. Lucie Appraisal Company prepares diminished value reports for exotic cars. Insurance companies fight auto diminished value claims tooth and nail but with a good appraisal and persistence, car owners can be fairly compensated. Attorneys who handle diminished value cases that don't have bodily injury attached to them are hard to find but probably not for a diminished value loss of this size. Most often these claims are settled without litigation if the diminished value appraisal is strong enough to convince insurance company defense attorneys that they would lose in court.


Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC