IF Tesla's Elon Musk Is NO LONGER CEO, Is TSLA Doomed Or Will It Be The Start Of A Smoother Future?

IF Tesla's Elon Musk Is NO LONGER CEO, Is TSLA Doomed Or Will It Be The Start Of A Smoother Future?
If one thing is apparent over the past month or so at Tesla, it's that Elon Musk isn't exactly the CEO we all once thought he was. Sure, he's been a part of some incredible breakthroughs and he's been a helluva visionary, but is he doing the CEO thing right?

It certainly doesn't seem like it.

In Musk's quest to do battle against the "bad guys," the short sellers, he may have sealed his own fate. We'll see in the coming months as the SEC's investigation ramps up.

According to a story in The New York Times, one expert notes the following:

...Peter Henning, professor of law at Wayne State University, said Mr. Musk’s tweet was “clearly incomplete disclosure,” adding that if the S.E.C. decided to pursue a fraud case, the consequences could be severe.

“The penalty that scares everyone is a director and officer bar,” Mr. Henning said. “If you are found to have misled investors, the S.E.C. can seek to bar you from serving as an officer or director of a public company. That could remove Elon Musk from Tesla.”

Mr. Musk also must contend with a shareholder lawsuit that challenges Tesla’s acquisition of SolarCity, his solar panel business. And he must try to replenish the executive ranks and stabilize Model 3 production, all while managing his volatile social life...

So, I am left wondering: IF Musk is NO LONGER TSLA's CEO, will that doom the electric vehicle manufacturer, or will that be the start of a smoother future for the brand?


Read Article

RunamukkRunamukk - 8/29/2018 1:15:44 AM
+1 Boost
I think the shareholder's faith in his vision is all that's keeping it afloat. Even that won't be enough when the experienced, luxury manufacturers enter this game in full force within the next couple of years.



senftsenft - 8/29/2018 7:08:30 AM
+2 Boost
Can Elon hire a competent manager and hiring one, would he let them manage? or is Elon too much of a toxic narcissist?


TomMTomM - 8/29/2018 7:31:25 AM
+3 Boost
The question is - DOES Tesla actually make a profit on anything? IF it "could" a professional corporate manager will be able to make Tesla better. ANd that is something Musk is not.


malba2367malba2367 - 8/29/2018 7:59:48 AM
+2 Boost
For the best interest of shareholders and the company there needs to be an operational person who is the COO, and keep Elon at CEO. This is the same setup Apple was so successful with where Steve Jobs was the idea man, promoter, and visible face of the company while Tim Cook was the guy who made it all happen. Elon is somewhat of a visionary with many ideas, and he needs a real operations person to make the practical ideas happen efficiently and with cost containment. Elon is also a great front man for Tesla and he is able to generate a lot of buzz around his products and brand.


Vette71Vette71 - 8/29/2018 9:59:06 AM
0 Boost
What worked at Apple2 was that Jobs had first failed as a CEO and been fired. He was a rare entrepreneur who learned from his failure that he needed a strong COO to run things and that he had to move away from the day to day. Musk isn't there and will drive any COO who comes in to add order and predictability. Musk trusts very few people; his tech leader, his CFO. his brother and his cousin. The rest he has pushed out. Prediction. The Board will insist on a COO, bring in someone who Musk will fire/push out, Musk will take back operational role, chaos will ensue, Board will fire Musk. This scenario has played out over and over in business history.


EVisNowEVisNow - 8/29/2018 12:05:26 PM
+1 Boost
It would be suicidal for the Board to fire Musk - if they could ever do that based on the existing structure. Without Musk, Tesla would have been another boutique EV maker like Lucid Motors or Faraday Future. With Musk, Tesla is "the future of sustainable transport" that encompasses several sectors as leaders, not just an automaker. The value in Tesla's autonomous driving alone is worth the current valuation.


PUGPROUDPUGPROUD - 8/29/2018 10:07:28 AM
+1 Boost
Stock drops 40%, company slowly put on sounder footing over 18 months and then put up for sale. The SEC and the Tesla board will not kick him out for fear that stock will take a huge hit...however if stock falls due to continuing issues under his leadership lead investors will call for him to step down. Not sure what price that is but my guess is $250 or less.


Vette71Vette71 - 8/29/2018 12:54:50 PM
-1 Boost
Exactly. SEC will slowly run the investigation and it will hang over the company. The operating results, vendor issues, cash, cash, cash will decide the fate of the stock. If it falls then investors will call for his head; Board works for investors and he works for the Board. His 20% share isn't enough to guarantee tenure.


mre30mre30 - 8/30/2018 12:20:56 PM
+2 Boost
There are plenty of talented auto executives out there - Musk should go and a replacement should be hired. Just don't hire DeNyscchen from Cadillac - he's a dud.

Musk should move on - he is a 'start-up' CEO and Tesla needs an operating CEO. Since he owns so much stock, he will still be part of the family, but he should no longer be the day-to-day chief.


Copyright 2026 AutoSpies.com, LLC